How do we keep this site running? This post may contain affiliate links — the cost is the same to you, but we get a referral fee. Compensation does not affect rankings. Thanks!
I am pretty certain that other cultures (and the cave men too) probably give their babies “real” food to explore with. I suspect that, somewhere along the line, someone thought it would be faster and more efficient (and safer) to puree food for a baby and I can see why it caught on. No one really likes to see her/his baby gag on anything. And, big chunks of food in a mouth that has no teeth is intimidating and scary to many parents. Purees make sense for babies, right? A growing movement called “Baby-Led Weaning” is touting that purees are NOT the way to go and that letting your baby explore food (being smart and safe about it) is a better way to transition your baby from a liquid to a solid food diet. This may be the oldest new method of weaning from breastfeeding for your baby.
The Theory Behind Baby-Led Weaning
The website, aptly named www.babyledweaning.com says, “Baby-led weaning is…a somewhat cheesy term for just letting your infant self-feed. You cut food up into manageable sticks and offer it, they eat. It’s really pretty simple.” For the most part, it is simple.
Babies have a strong gag reflex. My youngest baby even gagged on infant Tylenol and gripe water until he was about 4 months (it was lovely, let me tell you! Anything that touched his tongue other than breastmilk caused all of the breastmilk he had previously had to be ejected. If you’ve breastfed before, you know that this will drive you and your baby to tears to see that precious milk anywhere but in a bottle or your baby’s belly! ).
Tongue Thrust Reflex
Until they are approximately 4-6 months old, babies are programmed to basically push anything foreign out of their mouths. This is called the tongue thrust reflex and it essentially means that anything you put in that they are not accustomed to (and sometimes even something they are (ever tried to keep a pacifier in a newborn’s mouth???) will be pushed back out by the tongue. If you force something else in the baby’s mouth (like food) before the reflex is gone, it’s likely going to lead to a lot of frustration for both you and your baby. This is one reason doctors recommend waiting until at LEAST 4 months to start any sort of solids (The A.A.P. and W.H.O. both now recommend 6 months for breastfed babies to start weaning from breastfeeding. The recommendations also stem from babies having immature digestive systems and solids are just too hard on their little tummies and intestines.).
Even after 6 months, babies tend to continue to have a strong gag reflex. This is their natural protection against choking! This is where Baby-Led Weaning comes in. If a large chunk of food makes its way into baby’s mouth, this gag reflex will kick in and push it back out before it can lodge in the throat.
I’ve seen pictures and heard stories about parents giving baby a large pork chop (still on the bone) to gnaw on and baby had NO problem with it (and we’re talking a 6-7 month old baby here!). Babies will quickly learn to move the food around at the front of their mouth (which leads to learning to chew) and choking will not be an issue. Most Baby-Led Weaners tend to be cautious and not give babies foods that can easily lodge in the throat, but they, as a rule, stay away from purees which are just an extension of the baby’s already liquid diet.
My Experiences with Solid Food
My oldest, Jonathan, is now nine and is the pickiest eater alive (Well, that may be an exaggeration. He does eat broccoli, after all). My second youngest, Elijah, is a great eater (Micah, my second one, is somewhere in between.). Ironically, without knowing the name of it, Baby Led Weaning is essentially what we did to wean Elijah from breastfeeding, but maybe in a less extreme way than what some of the literature out there recommends.
Elijah didn’t show any interest in solids at all until close to 8 months, so I didn’t really push him. He tried a little here and there, but truly didn’t seem to want anything other than breastmilk until he was much older than my other two had been. By the time he was ready for solids, he really wanted “real food” and not mashed up purees. I gave him small pieces of what we were eating from almost day one and he did fine. So, I went with it since he really pretty much refused purees.
Isaac, my youngest, started showing interest a bit earlier, but now, at 8.5 months, still doesn’t have much of an appetite for solids. He likes to eat something when others are eating, but it’s far from his main source of food. Because of this (he has no interest in me shoveling food into his mouth!), I’ve let him explore the food that he eats even more than I did with Elijah. I have given him larger pieces of food earlier and just watched him like a hawk. To my surprise, he has gagged, but never come close to choking on anything. It’s messy, for sure, but he’s exploring foods like broccoli, melons, toast, waffles (no syrup!!!),… with no problems.
My Thoughts on Baby-Led Weaning From Breastfeeding?
I am way too nervous to give Isaac a pork chop or a drumstick to go to town on! That’s beyond my comfort zone. However, I DO think exploring foods helps babies to appreciate a wide range of textures and tastes while making the transition from liquid to solid foods go a little more smoothly. I, personally, tend to do a combination of purees/cereals and more solid chunks of food. This method of weaning from breastfeeding works best for me and my baby.
Advantages of Baby-Led Weaning
I think exploring food is good for many reasons beyond avoiding a picky child, including early development of fine motor skills, social skills (eating at the table like a “big boy/girl”!), and just building on natural curiosity. You have to be committed to letting your child set the pace and be comfortable with breastmilk or formula still, very much, being your baby’s main form of nutrients because they will not eat a lot for quite some time (although Isaac can put away some bread!). As I mentioned before, it can also be pretty messy! However, it’s a lot of fun and makes for great photo opportunities! Every meal is a fun adventure in our house and I wouldn’t have it any other way!
Looking for More Info on How to Transition Baby to Solids?
If you are interested in learning more detailed info as well as some recipe ideas for starting your baby on solids, check out our article on this subject. And if you have stories – successful or ones others can learn from, do not hesitate to leave a comment below. We welcome your anecdotes!