Best Online Thrift Stores & Consignment Websites: Swap vs ThredUp vs Poshmark vs Tradesy vs RealReal & More!

How do we keep this site running? This post may contain affiliate links — the cost is the same to you, but we get a referral fee. Compensation does not affect rankings. Thanks!

1st
2nd
3rd

Want to make some money off your gently used clothes and keep your unwanted stuff out of the landfills? You can sell used clothes through a thrift shop online! Some consignors have made more than $1,000 by utilizing these designer consignment websites.

Don’t have designer items? No worries, some of these companies sell clothes that aren’t designer focused. And you don’t even have to stop at clothes and shoes. Some of the best consignment websites also allow games, accessories, movies, books and more.

We’ll cover the pros, cons, commission rates, fees and more for the best online thrift stores. Find out where to sell clothes online by reading our online consignment reviews below and feel good about giving your garments a second life.

Swap Review

#1

Visit Website

Swap accepts new or gently used clothes, toys, games, movies, books and more. You can purchase from multiple sellers and have them shipped in one order. All items are shipped within one business day.

If you don’t like what you purchased, or it doesn’t fit, you can return it within 30-days. All you have to do is ship it back and you’ll get a full refund or store credit within five to ten days.

If you choose to sell your secondhand items through Swap, you can use a prepaid shipping label or Inbound Box to send your items. Then Swap will photograph, price, list, pack and store your items until they are sold. Once sold, you will earn your money.

If your items aren’t listed or sold you have the option to donate them or have them sent back to you for $5.99.

Pros

Cons

  • A+ rating on BBB
  • Can sell and buy household items in addition to clothes
  • Items ship within one business day (and multiple orders ship together)
  • Save up to 90% off original retail price when buying clothes
  • 30-day returns
  • Quality items for sale
  • Some consigners say it took months for Swap to go through their items
  • Items are priced by Swap
  • Many photos aren’t on mannequins

Commission Rates

  • Less than $10 sale: earn 30% credit or 20% cash
  • $10-$20 sale: earn 50% credit or 40% cash
  • Higher than $20: earn 70% credit or 60% cash

Poshmark Review

#2

Visit Website

Founded in 2011, Poshmark sells women’s, men’s and kids’ clothing as well as shoes, bags, jewelry, accessories and makeup. Instead of sending your items in to Poshmark, you take your own photos and upload them to your “closet.” You can then share your listings to your network to try and get your items sold.

You set the price of your items, so you won’t feel like your clothes were stolen from you. After your item sells, Poshmark provides a pre-paid label to send your items. After the package is delivered, you’ll get paid.

Poshmark is a popular choice for clothing sellers and there are also many options for you to improve your wardrobe. Sellers can create their own shops, some are very descriptive and thorough while others are a little more lazy with their listings.

Pros

Cons

  • B+ rating on BBB
  • No shipping costs for selling
  • App is easy to use
  • Save up to 70% off original retail price when buying clothes
  • Great online community
  • Items are priced by sellers
  • No household items
  • Some photos aren’t great since they’re taken by sellers
  • Complaints of accounts being shutdown with no warning
  • Shipping fee is not covered for sellers
  • Customer service complaints
  • All sales are final, no return policy

Seller Fees (No Commission Rate)

Poshmark charges a flat fee for each item sold and doesn’t necessarily have a “commission rate” like the other companies reviewed in this article.

  • Sales under $15: $2.95 fee
  • Sales more than $15: 20% fee

Tips for Using Poshmark

Below are tips specific to Poshmark, but you could also use them in any of these online consignment clothing stores.

ThredUp Review

#3

Visit Website

ThredUp was founded in 2009 as a peer-to-peer online sharing platform of men’s shirts. It has now extended far beyond selling just men’s shirts.

ThredUp specializes in women’s and kids’ clothing, but also has shoes, handbags and men’s clothing. The majority of its clothes are presented on a mannequin, so you get a pretty good idea of what the clothes would look like on you.

To sell your items through ThredUp, request a Clean Out Bag and put any items you want to sell in it. Ship it to ThredUp and the company will take photos and put the qualifying items up on its website for sale.

We’re a little disappointed that ThredUp only offers a 14-day return window compared to typical in-store purchases. You usually have at least 30-days to return retail store bought items.

We’re also bummed with the number of negative reviews we found for ThredUp. According to consumers, some haven’t received payment for their sold items or didn’t receive their unsold items returned back to them.

Pros

Cons

  • A+ rating on BBB
  • Save up to 90% off original retail price when buying clothes
  • Free clean out bag shipped to you to mail in items
  • Professional photos taken for you
  • Most photos are on mannequins to give you a sense of how it looks on a person
  • Must enter your email to shop the site
  • Some consumers say they didn’t receive payment for items sold
  • Consumers say they didn’t receive unsold items returned to them
  • Shorter return time frame compared to other sites

Commission Rates

  • Items listed less than $14.99: 95% for women’s, 90% for kids
  • Items listed between $15 to $19.99: 87% for women’s, 85% for kids
  • Items listed between $20 to $29.99: 82% for women’s, 80% for kids
  • Items listed between $30 to $39.99: 75% for women’s and kids
  • Items listed between $40 to $49.99: 70% for women’s and kids
  • Items listed between $50 to $59.99: 60% for women’s and kids
  • Items listed between $60 to $74.99: 55% for women’s and kids
  • Items listed between $75 to $89.99: 50% for women’s and kids
  • Items listed between $90 to $124.99: 45% for women’s and kids
  • Items listed between $125 to $199.99: 40% for women’s and kids
  • Items listed between $200 to $299.99: 30% for women’s and kids
  • Items listed $300 and up: 20% for women’s and kids

Other Online Consignment Shops

Below you’ll find an alphabetical listing of other companies we’ve reviewed that didn’t make our top three.

DepopRealReal | Tradesy

Depop Review

Depop logo

Visit Website

Depop isn’t very descriptive with how its consignment works. In fact, we had to do some digging to find out how Depop runs its consignment shop.

The website looks like Instagram. It’s filled with images of clothing, and when you select a piece of clothing an Instagram-like page comes up with hashtags, images and a blurb about the article of clothing.

You can choose to follow the shop owner, so you have access to view all of the items for sale on their shop in your feed. Sellers are in charge of taking their own photos and setting their prices.

Similar to eBay, you can bid on items instead of paying the price that is listed. The platform isn’t really for designer items and some items are made by people themselves.

Depop is popular among people under 30-years-old. Unfortunately, many people have been scammed using Depop, so we don’t recommend using it.

Pros

Cons

  • Many inexpensive clothing items
  • No return policy
  • No BBB page
  • Many sellers and buyers have been scammed by the opposite party

Commission Rates

  • 10% commission fee and a 3.4% + $0.30 PayPal transaction fee

RealReal Review

RealReal logo

Visit Website

You can consign through RealReal one of three ways. The first is to schedule an in-home pickup if you have more than ten items, which is free but only available in certain areas. If you have less than ten items, or in-home pickup isn’t available in your area, you can ship your items with a free shipping label. The final way is to visit a brick-and-mortar Luxury Consignment Office

After RealReal receives your items they will be photographed and priced by RealReal. This takes an average of 10-15 days.

Unless you have a lot of high dollar items, you’ll be missing out on a lot of the profits of your sold items.

Pros

Cons

  • A+ BBB rating
  • Flexible ways to sell (pick up, mail or in person)
  • Professionally photographed items
  • Save up to 70% off original retail price when buying clothes
  • Must enter your email to shop the site
  • Must request a return within 14-days and it must be received within 21-days
  • Items are priced by RealReal
  • Customers complain that they’ve received fake or poor quality items
  • No response to negative reviews on BBB, only positive reviews
  • Charges sellers a $100 fee for fine art pieces and $15 for other items

Commission Rates

  • 70% for net sales of $10,000 or more
  • 60% for net sales of $1,501-$9,999
  • 55% for net sales of $201-$1,500
  • 50% for net sales of $200 or less

$100 fee for fine art pieces and $15 fee for other items sold.

Tradesy Review

Tradesy logo

Visit Website

Launched in 2012, Tradesy’s goal is to have every product have five owners in its lifetime. Tradesy wants designer products to be affordable and accessible to everyone.

You can list your authentic, designer clothing, bags, shoes and accessories on Tradesy within 60 seconds directly through its app. Tradesy selects the price for you and charges a flat price or fee depending on the sales price.

Tradesy even has a wedding category that sells wedding gowns, bridesmaid dresses and other wedding gear. However, there are random items like stocking caps in this category that don’t fit what we consider to be traditional wedding attire.

Pros

Cons

  • Wedding and bridesmaid dresses
  • Save up to 70% off original retail price when buying clothes
  • Items are priced by sellers
  • Returns must be requested within 4-days
  • Sellers have fees taken out of their sales
  • Not BBB accredited
  • Sellers say it can take weeks to get profits

Commission Rates

  • $7.50 commission fee for items less than $50
  • 19.8% commission fee for items more than $50

Reduce, Reuse, Resell (and Make Some Money too!)

We hope our article has helped you choose the best online consignment to use to sell your gently used items. You can definitely have a positive impact on our planet and earn a decent chunk of money by utilizing an online designer consignment service. Why stop at selling your clothes, though?

Do you have old electronics that you no longer use? You can sell your old smartphones and computers through one of these electronic recycling companies.

Would you consider selling your gently used items on one of these websites?

One of Kimberly’s favorite things to do is cook. She is trying her best to be more conscious about the nutrients she puts into her body and enjoys trying new recipes. Kimberly grew up helping her dad with the family garden and hopes to have her own garden some day. She enjoys brightening up her dishes with the food mother nature can provide and enjoys composting her produce scraps.

Leave a Reply

Be the First to Comment!

Send this to a friend