Best Compost Bin: A Down and Dirty Comparison

To sustain this free service, we receive affiliate commissions via some of our links. This doesn’t affect rankings. Our review process.

Best Indoor Compost Bin
Best Outdoor Compost Bin
1st Place
LINKYO logo
2nd Place
3rd Place

Looking for the best compost bin but feeling lost in the weeds?

Composting is a great way to reduce your carbon footprint while also creating fertilizer to help your garden flourish. In our experience it also decreased kitchen odor from food rot in the trash can while also reducing your amount of trash, especially if you combine it with recycling.

Get ready to toss your scraps into a stylish and smell-free system while lowering your impact on the landfill!

Best Compost Bin Reviews

If you’re new to composting, we’ve got a handy guide for beginners which goes into all the nitty-gritty details about why you should compost, the history of the process and more. So, that’s a good place to start. If you already know all about it, jump right into our composter reviews to find out which containers will best meet your needs.

There are a number of things you’ll want to consider before purchasing a compost bin, including how much room you have on your countertop and in your yard. You’ll also want to carefully examine you and your family’s lifestyle.

Indoor vs Outdoor Compost Container

If you live in an apartment and eat out a lot, then you might be better off with a smaller, indoor bin. Composting containers for kitchen are also a great way to “save up” your scraps throughout the week and then use it to transfer the scraps to a larger outdoor bin to start the process of turning trash into gardening gold! Don’t worry, we’ve reviewed those so you can find the best kitchen compost bin that meets your lifestyle and style.

If you have a spacious yard and tend to cook frequently, then a larger outdoor bin is definitely the way to go. And if you have an outdoor bin, you might want to get an indoor bin as well to keep scraps for the short-term. No matter which route you go, we’ve found the best of the best bins so you can compost with confidence.

Our website’s founder uses at his house – an indoor canister for scraps during the week which gets dumped in the outdoor compost container when it fills up.

Best Indoor Compost Bins | Best Outdoor Compost Bins

Indoor Compost Bins

The first thing to know if you get a counter compost bin, is you will need charcoal filters to keep the odor in and keep the fruit flies out! Here’s the best value we found that also fits most sized containers: Estilo Compost Pail Filters.

Best Indoor Compost Bin: LINKYO Kitchen Compost Bin

Linkyo compost bin View on Amazon

Our top pick for the best indoor compost bin goes to LINKYO. The stainless steel design is not only sleek to match existing stainless steel appliances, the material and ventilation holes also help prevent odor.

In addition to making an attractive countertop compost bin, it’s dishwasher safe to clean or to help mitigate wear and tear, you can line it with a bag. There is a handle for easy transportation to your outdoor compost bin. You can set this bin out on the countertop or under the sink if you’re short on shelf space (or worried about fruit flies).

Made from high-grade stainless steel that is scratch and rust free, it also earns our top pick for the best beginner’s compost bin.

Pros

Cons

  • Sleek, modern design
  • Stainless steel and charcoal liner keeps odor out
  • Lightweight for carrying outside
  • Affordable
  • 1 gallon capacity
  • 100% Lifetime Warranty
  • Our personal experience with this bin over 3+ years: no fruit fly issues
  • Holes can let fruit flies in
  • Large size can take up a lot of counter space

Price: $22.95

2nd Place: Compost Bin

Chef'N EcoCrockView on Amazon

Next on our list for best countertop composter is the the Chef’N EcoCrock. It’s a more modern option for those who have a green thumb. It a super sleek kitchen compost container that can hold up to 3 quarts of food scraps and is made from ceramic with a plastic lid to keep out smell.

There is also a handy green plastic bin inside with a handle that easily removes to transport to your outdoor bin or garden. From looking at the container you wouldn’t be able to tell it was a composter (other than maybe the leaf handle on top).

And again, you can use charcoal discs to help with odor and plastic bags if you wish to keep your EcoCrock clean (not sure this is the most earth-friendly idea but to each their own 😉 ).

Pros

Cons

  • Affordable yet stylish
  • Smaller size takes up less counter space
  • Ceramic outer container helps keep down odor
  • Dual buckets to create easy transport to/from kitchen
  • Not designed to match all tastes
  • Ceramic can chip or break over time
  • People complain about lid not shutting completely

Price: $31.89

3rd Place: Sure-Close Kitchen Composter

Sure-Close Kitchen ComposterView on Amazon

Rounding out the top three is the Sure-Close. What we love about this bin is its flexibility; you can attach it to the cabinet under the sink, hide it in a pantry or place it on the counter. It has a click-open top that stays lifted when you need to dump your waste, a convenient feature for when your hands are full.

It also has a large capacity and a microperforated lid that seals out bugs while also allowing air to flow to reduce the stink. When you’re ready to compost, simply remove the plastic bag inside (sold separately) or take outside using the handy handle.

Keep in mind that if you throw away the plastic bag in the garbage you are defeating the purpose of composting so be sure you have a place to dump it where it can naturally compost outside, ideally an outdoor bin or perhaps you can donate it to a local community garden.

Pros

Cons

  • Flexible options for where to store
  • Large capacity, holds up to 2 gallons
  • Seal tight rim prevents bugs and odors
  • Lightweight HDPE, UV protected plastic that will not break
  • Low-price
  • Less attractive design
  • Plastic is less eco-friendly
  • Material is more prone to attracting flies or odor
  • Bigger size means it takes up more space

Price: $19.55

Outdoor Compost Bins

If you decide to use outdoor composting bins, there are various types of systems from which to choose, from worm composters to portable ones. However, we prefer the self-contained systems that require minimum work so you can start composting quickly with the least amount of effort or experience. More specifically, you’ll see there are two types: either a stationary and 2 outdoor composter.

Compost Tumblers

A compost tumbler is ones that spins on an axis point and is slightly elevated. The frequent spinning helps the scraps to be exposed to oxygen more frequently than if it just sits on top of itself (stationary). The tumbling speeds up the composting process. On the flip side (pun intended), a stationary container will require you to manually use a pitch fork to turn the scraps on a regular basis to ensure continuous composting.

Best Outdoor Compost Bin: Envirocycle Composter Composteamaker

Envirocycle Composter ComposteamakerView on Amazon

If you’re looking for the best compost tumbler then look no further than the Envirocycle. It coins itself “The Most Beautiful Composter in the World” and users agree that Envirocycle is the Cadillac of composters. Its loyal and compassionate users swear by this subtle yet powerful tool for producing compost for the gardens.

While it’s a little on the pricey side, people say it’s well worth it! It comes in two sizes, so if you want to start off small, you can always add a second one later instead of starting off with a double chamber tumbler (many people love them and have multiples).

These durable spinning barrels are crafted in the U.S. with recycled and new materials using a refined manufacturing process which minimizes packaging, reducing consumer waste. Turn it 3 times every 3 days, and after 4 to 8 weeks you’ll have nutritious fertilizer for your yard so long as you follow the ingredient ratio recommended here.

Since this is a tumbler, it’s also our pick for best compost tumbler.

Pros

Cons

  • Made in the U.S. using high quality UV protected, BPA-free materials
  • No assembly required
  • Great customer service reputation
  • Comes with 5 year limited warranty
  • Comes in two sizes: mini and regular
  • No negative Amazon reviews
  • Higher price tag than some other options
  • Doesn’t spin well in frozen temps (although you need heat to compost anyways)
  • Door latch can break over time with use (but they replace free of charge if you are within the warranty)

Price for 35 Gallon: $229.99

Video: Composting 101 With Envirocycle

Watch this 40 second video on how easy it is to compost using Envirocycle.

2nd Place: Yimby Tumbler Composter

Yimby Tumbler Composter View on Amazon

The Yimby is our second place pick in our composter reviews. It has a divider inside that allows you to store your compost that is further along on one-side so it is ready to go into the garden, while the other side “cooks” your newer scraps that are not yet ready for the garden.

It also spins so you don’t have to spend a time and energy turning the compost manually with a pitchfork. It does require some assembly, but there is an instructional video for set up. Its 37-gallon capacity is large enough to hold plenty of compost without taking up a ton of space in your yard or garden.

Note: it requires direct sunlight, so make sure you have a spot where it can get build up some heat.

Pros

Cons

  • Composts in 4-6 weeks
  • Dual-chamber
  • Made from recycled plastic that will not rot
  • Self-spinning so no pitch fork turning required
  • Above ground so rodents are less likely to get inside
  • Assembly required which can be time consuming
  • Screws can rust with wear and tear
  • Some complain about it being flimsy or leaking

Price: $99.95

3rd Place: Fiskars 75 gallon Eco Compost Bin

Fiskars 75 gallon Eco Compost BinView on Amazon

This large capacity mesh bin is ideal for the gardener with a small space or shared living area. Since it’s lightweight and collapsible, the Fiskars bin can easily be transported or stored when not in use. It has an open bottom, and a round shape to help distribute heat evenly.

The open air design allows worms and air in to help speed up the breakdown process. Although it’s pretty big, the design is sleek and minimal compared to other outdoor composting bins, so it won’t be an eye sore for yourself or your neighbors.

Unlike the other two tumbler composters we recommend, this one requires you to manually turn the compost with a pitch fork, and since it’s not solid plastic, the durable mesh might not hold up as well to critters. On the plus side, it is pretty affordable, and if you are new to composting and want to experiment, this is a good choice.

Pros

Cons

  • Lightweight, easy to set up (no assembly)
  • Easy spring-loaded design allows for storage when not in use
  • Affordable for outdoor bin
  • Large 75-Gallon capacity
  • Lid can pop off so rodents can easily get in
  • Mesh expands and/or is easily punctured (another rodent concern)
  • Lightweight design can tip over (if not using stakes)

Price: Check on Amazon

More Tips on Composting

We hope our compost bin reviews have helped you find the best compost bin for your needs. Whether you have a countertop compost container or one that’s in your yard, you can learn more about the art of composting in our homemade composting article. That goes into more depth about what you can (and cannot) compost, how the composting process works, composting tips and more.

Also check out The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s website which has some useful articles and resources for you to dig deeper (pun intended). Good luck growing and gardening!

Have you ever composted? What is your favorite type of compost bin and why?

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
Sadie is a vegetarian and an avid recycler who loves riding her bike and practicing yoga. She is passionate about the planet, conserving life’s precious resources and making the world a better place for generations to come. A big fan of up-cycling, Sadie loves yard sales and vintage stores to find new uses for old things. She loves to cook, clean and enjoy the many parks and outdoor spaces in DC where she currently resides with her husband.

Leave a Reply

3 Comments on "Best Compost Bin: A Down and Dirty Comparison"

newest oldest most voted
Kimberly Alt
I have the Linkyo compost bin for inside and we’ve been having problems with gnats the past few weeks. I think this would happen with any compost bin, but does anyone have any ideas on how to get rid of gnats safely? (And keep them away?) FYI, other than that, the Linkyo compost bin has been AMAZING. We haven’t changed the filter yet (and have had it for almost a year) and it hasn’t started to smell. I’m completely shocked with how great this works! Plus, it’s super easy to clean. I’ve hand washed it and put it in the dishwasher before, either way works great!
Katie Brown
I’ve been wanting to start composting for years and think I’m finally ready to commit to it. Glad to see there are some indoor options that won’t stink up our place, because we live in a condo building that doesn’t have an outdoor area where we can compost outdoors. But I do have a small garden and would like to have some healthy, nutritious fertilizer to help it grow (while also helping reduce my carbon footprint by recycling my waste). With the indoor composting bins though, what happens once they start to fill up? Can you turn it into compost indoors or does it need to be transferred to a larger, more traditional composting bin to turn into fertilizer? Thanks!

Send this to a friend